A federal court in Florida has dismissed an antitrust suit filed against BTC.com founder Roger Ver and several other prominent figures in the crypto industry, accused of market manipulation during a contentious split of the BTC Cash network in November 2018, Law360 reported.
Other defendants in the case included Kraken CEO Jesse Powell, former CEO of Bitmain Technologies Jihan Wu, as well as BTC Cash developers Shammah Chancellor and Jason Cox.
First filed by United American Corp (UAC) in December 2018 and amended in March 2020, the lawsuit claimed that the defendants colluded to manipulate the cryptocurrency market to favor as some participants on the network were engaged in creating a competing clone called .
During the BTC SV hard fork—an event when a network splits in two separate chains—the defendants allegedly “hijacked” the BTC Cash network and “violated all accepted standards and protocols associated with BTC since its inception.”
However, on Wednesday, April 1, Judge Chris McAliley of the Southern District of Florida dismissed the case. According to the ruling, to be considered by the court the complaint “must state facts–not conclusions–that plausibly suggest a conspiracy.”
At least two of two of UAC’s counts in complaint are direct allegations lacking in substance, the judge said.
Centralizing the network
In technical terms, the lawsuit claimed that Ver, Wu and Bitmain Technologies took 90,000 BTC mining machines—Antminers that were running on BTC’s original network—and switched them over to mine BTC Cash. This, the lawsuit claimed, increased the hashing power of Ver’s BTC.com mining pool by over 4,000%, effectively centralizing the BTC Cash network.
“The week before the software upgrade, the BTC.com and Bitmain Technologies mining pools were collectively awarded 20.1% of the blocks,” read the complaint. “On November 16, 2018, the day after the upgrade, those same mining pools were awarded 98.85% of the blocks on the BTC Cash network.”
Additionally, the defendants’ actions allegedly influenced the market prices of BTC (BTC), BTC Cash (BCH), and BTC SV (BSV), as well forced UAC out of the network after the Miami-based company invested over $4 million in its infrastructure.
Cryptocurrency exchange Kraken was accused of initially refusing to list BSV on its platform after it released a public statement saying that “BTC SV does not presently meet Kraken’s listing requirements and is unlikely to be supported.” Three days after BTC SV forked away from BTC Cash, BSV was, in fact, listed on Kraken, however.
Yet, as stated by Judge McAliley, “after a painstaking review of the complaint, the court concluded that it lacks facts that create a reasonable expectation that discovery will reveal evidence of illegal agreement.”
BTC Cash–a long and windy road
BTC Cash emerged in August 2017 as a hard fork of the original blockchain after a group of developers backed by a number of large companies, mining pool operators, and individual investors responded to calls to increase the block size from 1MB to 8MB.
Another group of BTC developers and enthusiasts joined forces behind Segregated Witness (SegWit), a BTC upgrade aimed at increasing the block size limit by removing certain pieces of data from transactions.
Over time BTC Cash’s block size has grown from 8MB to 32MB, however, disagreements within the project were mounting as well, ultimately resulting in another hard fork and the establishment of BTC SV (Satoshi’s Vision) in November 2018.
Led by the self-proclaimed BTC creator Craig Wright, BSV was designed as an alternative software to the BTC ABC implementation of BTC Cash. The latter included Roger Ver and Jihan Wu among its backers.
Nearly two and half years later, the two projects are living their own lives, with BTC Cash undergoing yet another hard fork in November 2020.