Tuesday, July 8, 2025
  • About us
  • Economic Calendar
  • Price Predictions
  • Coins Alerts
  • Crypto Portfolio Tracker
  • Exclusively from Our Partners
Cryptheory
  • Cryptocurrency List
  • Cryptocurrency
    • Cryptocurrency Exchanges
      • Top exchanges for trading Bitcoin derivatives
      • How to buy bitcoin without KYC
      • How to Trade Bitcoin – best platforms
      • Best platforms to buy Bitcoin by debit or credit card
      • Platforms for Grid Trading
      • BYDFi: Review and Guide
      • BingX: Review and Guide
      • Kraken: Review and Guide
      • Bybit: Review and Guide
      • Bitpanda: Review and Guide
      • Phemex: Review and Guide
      • Huobi: Quick Guide
      • Binance: Review and Guide
        • Binance Futures Guide
    • Bitcoin
    • Tether
    • XRP
    • Dogecoin
    • Avalanche
    • Stellar
    • The Open Network
  • crypto news
  • Crypto Exchanges Info
  • Analysis
  • Attractions
No Result
View All Result
  • Cryptocurrency List
  • Cryptocurrency
    • Cryptocurrency Exchanges
      • Top exchanges for trading Bitcoin derivatives
      • How to buy bitcoin without KYC
      • How to Trade Bitcoin – best platforms
      • Best platforms to buy Bitcoin by debit or credit card
      • Platforms for Grid Trading
      • BYDFi: Review and Guide
      • BingX: Review and Guide
      • Kraken: Review and Guide
      • Bybit: Review and Guide
      • Bitpanda: Review and Guide
      • Phemex: Review and Guide
      • Huobi: Quick Guide
      • Binance: Review and Guide
        • Binance Futures Guide
    • Bitcoin
    • Tether
    • XRP
    • Dogecoin
    • Avalanche
    • Stellar
    • The Open Network
  • crypto news
  • Crypto Exchanges Info
  • Analysis
  • Attractions
No Result
View All Result
Cryptheory
No Result
View All Result

Is LUNA a giant Ponzi scheme?

by cryptheory
April 10, 2022
in Attractions
Reading Time: 6 mins read

Table of Contents

  • But how exactly does this algorithmic stablecoin work?
  • Terra USD: Stability through arbitrage
  • Challenges with algorithmic stablecoins
  • Stablecoins: how does such a failure come about?
  • Anchor Protocol: Another key piece of this debate
  • Rough overview of Anchor’s expenses and income
  • Terra USD a Ponzi scheme?
  • Arguments of the LUNA advocates
  • Terra USD: The bet remains exciting

LUNA is the native token of the Terra Blockchain. One of the goals of the Terra Blockchain is to provide decentralized algorithmic stablecoins for the DeFi ecosystem. The most famous stablecoin from Terra is TerraUSD (UST).

But how exactly does this algorithmic stablecoin work?

Like other stablecoins, UST aims to maintain a steady value of $1. As an algorithmic stablecoin, however, this is not covered by a deposited security, but is dependent on created market incentives and arbitrage in order to be able to maintain its targeted value of 1 USD.

This is done by providing the on-chain option at any time to exchange UST and Luna at a fixed exchange rate. More specifically, you can burn (destroy) a dollar’s worth of Luna at any time and mint (create) a UST for it. Conversely, a UST can be burned at any time – in return, the protocol minted a dollar worth of Luna.

Is LUNA a giant Ponzi scheme?
Burn and Mint Mechanism by Luna/UST.

Terra USD: Stability through arbitrage

This possibility of minting and burning exists at all times, regardless of exchange rates in other markets (e.g. centralized exchanges such as binance Etc.).

So if the UST rate deviates from the targeted value of one US dollar, an arbitrage opportunity arises immediately. This is best illustrated with an example:

UST=1.05 USD

Is LUNA a giant Ponzi scheme?

Assumption: We own 1 Luna with a market value of 100 USD.

Strategy: Burn 1 Luna (value: 100 USD) for 100 UST, sell UST on offchain exchange for 105 USD

Profit: $5

Result: Selling pressure on UST increases, price tends back to 1 UST=1 US dollar

UST=0.95USD

An image containing text, device, gauge.  Automatically generated description

Assumption: We own 1 Luna with a market value of $100.

Strategy: Buy 100 UST on off-chain exchange for 95 US dollars, minting Luna worth 100 US dollars (here = 1 Luna)

Profit: $5

Result: increased demand for UST, price tends back to 1 UST = 1 US dollar

These are the mechanics of an algorithmic stablecoin – the supply of UST and Luna is dynamically regulated and the incentives are set in such a way that the price of UST tends towards $1 again and again.

Challenges with algorithmic stablecoins

So Luna’s role appears to include absorbing UST’s price volatility. So far so good. So what is the danger of algorithmic stablecoins?

Well, UST is not the first algorithmic stablecoin of its kind. A look at comparable projects paints a bleak picture:

Is LUNA a giant Ponzi scheme?
Failure of the Empty Set Dollar algorithmic stablecoin project.
Is LUNA a giant Ponzi scheme?
Failure of the algorithmic stablecoin project Basis Cash
What went wrong with $IRON finance / $TITAN token price?  It is not a rug pull but a bank run.  Firstly the token was massively pumped after billion - Twitter thread from
Probably the most famous algorithmic stablecoin project: Titan/IRON.

Conclusion: The stablecoins of these projects have no value today, although they should have a value of 1 USD.

Stablecoins: how does such a failure come about?

The major threat to such projects is a scenario where UST is trading below $1 (e.g. on exchanges like binance or Uniswap – the exchange rate on-chain always stays the same). As we have learned, arbitrageurs then buy UST, burn it on-chain for Luna and sell Luna off-chain. This increases the price of UST, but at the same time there is strong price pressure on Luna. If this price pressure becomes too high, a death spiral can occur, which results in the results shown above.

Because: If the price of Luna falls unexpectedly quickly (e.g. due to realized regulatory risks or capital flight to another ecosystem or similar) and investors lose confidence or fear that the targeted exchange rate of USD 1 cannot be maintained, they burn their UST for Luna to then sell it afterwards. However, we have learned that for each burned UST Luna worth 1 USD must be mined – as the Luna price falls, more and more Luna have to be mined for each UST burned, which can lead to a vicious circle and hyperinflation.

Is LUNA a giant Ponzi scheme?
 Development of a vicious circle: Luna price falls, people lose confidence in Luna, UST is burned against LUNA, LUNA is sold off, LUNA price falls.

Anchor Protocol: Another key piece of this debate

Anchor is the largest loan/loan protocol in the Terra ecosystem. It is characterized by extremely high interest rates on the UST stablecoin (about 20 percent per year). It is therefore not surprising that anchor is a strong driver of demand for UST – around 70 percent of all UST in circulation are deposited on the anchor protocol and generate interest.

Is LUNA a giant Ponzi scheme?
Value of Deposited Capital (TVL) on Anchor.

At the same time, borrowers deposit tokens like bLuna (bonded Luna) or bETH (bonded ETH) as collateral and borrow UST from the anchor protocol. While these borrowers are required to pay interest on the UST they borrow, due to ongoing incentive programs, they receive Anchor Protocol tokens at the same time — effectively, they are paid to borrow in UST

The question now arises as to how Anchor can finance the 20 percent interest rate on the stablecoins. (In comparison: In most other DeFi ecosystems, a maximum of 11-13% interest can currently be expected for stablecoins).

Rough overview of Anchor’s expenses and income

expenditure: Sum of all deposited UST multiplied by 1.2 = annual interest to be paid out

revenue: Interest income through forgiven UST credits (note: since the incentive programs mentioned above are implemented with the protocol’s own token, there is minimal to no additional costs for Anchor)

+

Staking income, which can be achieved with the bLuna and bETH deposited as collateral.

An image that contains text.  Automatically generated description
The ratio of deposited (green) and loaned capital (white) on the anchor protocol diverges greatly.

As can be surmised from Figure 7, Anchor’s revenues are currently smaller than its expenses, which is why the protocol needs to draw on its reserves to cover the deficit and continue paying such attractive interest rates on UST. The anchor team has already had to increase reserves twice so that the current growth strategy with the high subsidized stablecoin interest rates can be continued.

The crucial question now is how stable the Terra ecosystem is when the 20 percent interest on UST can no longer be maintained and as a logical consequence at least part of the capital flows to other chains.

Terra USD a Ponzi scheme?

This is where Luna’s Ponzi criticism comes in. Luna’s price is artificially inflated by Anchor paying an unsustainable 20 percent interest on UST over the long term. This causes large amounts of Luna to be burned, causing Luna’s price to increase. However, if Anchor has to lower the offered interest on UST, investors withdraw their funds, which leads to an increased burn rate of UST, causing Luna to be mined. This Luna will then be sold off.

In combination, on the one hand, the Luna price drops due to the sale and, on the other hand, the Luna supply increases exponentially because more and more Luna has to be mined per UST burned. The price pressure on Luna occurs twice. The losers are the other users of the Terra ecosystem, who bought Luna at increased prices to use the Terra blockchain.

In addition, a possible liquidation cascade on the anchor protocol and the resulting price pressure on Luna also represent a potential systemic risk.

Arguments of the LUNA advocates

At this point, Luna supporters will argue that Luna (in contrast to other algorithmic stablecoins) has an entire ecosystem with differentiated use cases such as payment of gas fees, staking, etc. behind it. The close link between the Luna Coin and the success of the Terra ecosystem as such means that the coin will be forced to participate in the success of the ecosystem in the long term – the only way is up so to speak.

The Anchor Team also recently increased its reserves to USD 450 million, a not inconsiderable cushion that could also be used in an emergency situation to maintain UST’s target price. This is rumored to have happened as early as this January, when UST after the Drama about Wonderland Finance veered off course or slumped even more sharply than was already the case.

At the same time, it was announced that additional coins (such as SOL or ATOM) will soon be accepted on the Anchor protocol as possible collateral for loans, so that the protocol will open up additional revenue opportunities in the future if the holders of these coins take out loans on Anchor and pay interest on them.

At the same time, funds are currently being raised for a BTC fund of around 3 billion. BTC purchases of around 1.3 billion US dollars have already taken place and are probably partly responsible for the current price increase. This BTC fund has the sole purpose of defending the UST rate during critical market times. The strong independence of BTC from the Terra ecosystem – especially compared to Luna or other assets – creates extremely strong protection for UST.

Terra USD: The bet remains exciting

Opinions in the crypto world are divided; one thing is certain: the Terra ecosystem is not without risk. If you want to benefit from the attractive interest rates from UST or otherwise participate financially in the various applications on the Terra Blockchain, you simply have to do so with the certainty of the risks involved.

Google Authenticator Guide

  • Author
  • Recent Posts
cryptheory
cryptheory
Core team behind Cryptheory Labs and website Cryptheory.org.
cryptheory
Latest posts by cryptheory (see all)
  • Why Online Advertisers Should Request Website Traffic Data from Google Analytics Instead of Using SEO Tools Like MOZ or Ahrefs? - March 24, 2025
  • North Carolina’s Bold Move: State Bill Proposes Investing 10% of Public Funds in Bitcoin - March 22, 2025
  • Justin Sun Stakes $100 Million in Ethereum on Lido – What Does It Mean for the Market? - March 19, 2025
Tags: LUNA
Previous Post

Nvidia Omniverse: Build your Metaverse

Next Post

Land prices in metaverse have fallen, is it time to buy?

Related Posts

10 Brilliant Reasons I’m Still Holding My 2018 Altcoin Bag (And Totally Not Crying Inside)
Attractions

10 Brilliant Reasons I’m Still Holding My 2018 Altcoin Bag (And Totally Not Crying Inside)

July 1, 2025
The Centralized Trap: Is Web3 Quietly Turning Back Into Web2?
Attractions

The Centralized Trap: Is Web3 Quietly Turning Back Into Web2?

June 24, 2025
Staking: Is it Just a Fancy Ponzi Scheme? Let's Get Real.
Uncategorized

Staking: Is it Just a Fancy Ponzi Scheme? Let’s Get Real.

June 11, 2025
Who Really Makes Bank on Memecoins – And Why It Ain't You, You Beautiful Degenerate
Attractions

Who Really Makes Bank on Memecoins – And Why It Ain’t You, You Beautiful Degenerate

June 4, 2025
Let’s Be Honest: Most Crypto Projects Are Just Bullshit Wrapped in a Sexy Website
Attractions

Let’s Be Honest: Most Crypto Projects Are Just Bullshit Wrapped in a Sexy Website

May 15, 2025
Ethereum Is Just a Pricier Solana – Let the Maxis Rage All They Want
Attractions

Ethereum Is Just a Pricier Solana – Let the Maxis Rage All They Want

May 14, 2025
What Exchanges Won’t Tell You – Part 2: Staking Scams & Launchpad Lies
Attractions

What Exchanges Won’t Tell You – Part 2: Staking Scams & Launchpad Lies

May 12, 2025
What Exchanges Won’t Tell You: How They’ll Milk You Even in a Bull Market - Part 1
Attractions

What Exchanges Won’t Tell You: How They’ll Milk You Even in a Bull Market – Part 1

May 12, 2025
Why You Should NEVER Hire a Hitman on the Darknet with Crypto (Unless You Want to Ruin Your Life)
Attractions

Why You Should NEVER Hire a Hitman on the Darknet with Crypto (Unless You Want to Ruin Your Life)

April 30, 2025
Please login to join discussion
Track all markets on TradingView
Score: 0
Game Over

Popular

Bitcoin: Everyone’s Scared, But The Charts Are Screaming “It Ain’t Over!”

Bitcoin: Everyone’s Scared, But The Charts Are Screaming “It Ain’t Over!”

June 25, 2025
SOL's Big F***ing Breakout: Why Solana's About to Send You to the Moon

SOL’s Big F***ing Breakout: Why Solana’s About to Send You to the Moon

June 10, 2025
Altseason Is Coming: Time to Saddle Up, Degens

Altseason Is Coming: Time to Saddle Up, Degens

June 20, 2025
Analysis & Trading Tips June 10, 2025: Dogecoin Is Barking Again

Analysis & Trading Tips June 10, 2025: Dogecoin Is Barking Again

June 10, 2025
Solana On-Chain Frenzy: New Addresses, Spikes, and Degens Running Wild

Solana On-Chain Frenzy: New Addresses, Spikes, and Degens Running Wild

June 12, 2025
Bitcoin Price Analysis & Trading Tips – June 9, 2025

Bitcoin Price Analysis & Trading Tips – June 9, 2025

June 9, 2025
Ethereum Is Cooking Again: Are You Gonna Ride or Cry?

Ethereum Is Cooking Again: Are You Gonna Ride or Cry?

June 30, 2025
Ethereum’s Not Dead Yet: On-Chain Data Screams Rebound & Trading Tips

Ethereum’s Not Dead Yet: On-Chain Data Screams Rebound & Trading Tips

June 27, 2025
2025 Déjà Vu? Why This Bitcoin Dump Might Just Be Your 2020 Moment All Over Again

2025 Déjà Vu? Why This Bitcoin Dump Might Just Be Your 2020 Moment All Over Again

June 23, 2025
BTC Analysis & Trading Tips: Bitcoin’s Banging on Resistance – Is It Time to Moon or Nuke?

BTC Analysis & Trading Tips: Bitcoin’s Banging on Resistance – Is It Time to Moon or Nuke?

June 25, 2025

💥 What's Your Crypto Trading Spirit Animal?

1. Your reaction to a red 15% candle?

2. How do you read charts?

3. What’s your biggest trading sin?

4. Favorite indicator?

5. How do you set your stop-loss?

6. What's your ideal trading environment?

7. How do you handle losing trades?

8. What’s your position sizing like?

9. What's your backup plan if you get liquidated?

10. Your crypto endgame?

Crypto News

Bitcoin

Ethereum

Altcoins

Cryptocurrency

Platforms for Copy Trading

Platforms for Grid Trading

Glossary of trading and crypto terms

Crypto Portfolio Tracker

 

Cryptheory Labs Projects

Guest Post for Free

On our website, you can share your opinions and insights. This feature is reserved for non-promotional articles. We are already working on a system for donations and rewarding every author.

This website is here for those of you who want to be at the forefront of innovation and new technologies like Bitcoin. But first, we need to tackle the challenges and survive in the unforgiving world of crypto assets. THIS IS CRYPTHEORY!

Follow Us

  • Terms Of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • About us
  • Contact us

© 2024 Cryptheory - F**k the forex, we want gains!

Shiba Inu loading
No Result
View All Result
  • Cryptocurrency List
  • Cryptocurrency
    • Cryptocurrency Exchanges
      • Top exchanges for trading Bitcoin derivatives
      • How to buy bitcoin without KYC
      • How to Trade Bitcoin – best platforms
      • Best platforms to buy Bitcoin by debit or credit card
      • Platforms for Grid Trading
      • BYDFi: Review and Guide
      • BingX: Review and Guide
      • Kraken: Review and Guide
      • Bybit: Review and Guide
      • Bitpanda: Review and Guide
      • Phemex: Review and Guide
      • Huobi: Quick Guide
      • Binance: Review and Guide
    • Bitcoin
    • Tether
    • XRP
    • Dogecoin
    • Avalanche
    • Stellar
    • The Open Network
  • crypto news
  • Crypto Exchanges Info
  • Analysis
  • Attractions

© 2024 Cryptheory - F**k the forex, we want gains!

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.